When Sam and Dean are killed by hunters, they end up in Heaven. They discover they must find Joshua, an angel who speaks directly with God, before Zachariah can find them.

The brothers investigate when the dead come to life in Bobby’s hometown… but are happy, content, and living peacefully with their families. Bobby is reunited with his dead wife and tells them not to worry, but Sam and Dean insist on staying and discover that the zombies have an ulterior motive.

The brothers take on Cupid when the people of a small town start killing each other in the name of love. However, they soon discover that a greater power is responsible.

The brothers take on Cupid when the people of a small town start killing each other in the name of love. However, they soon discover that a greater power is responsible.

While the brothers are on a case, Sam is targeted by a high school student who has learned a body-switching spell. Dean discovers his brother is now more interested in getting drunk and hitting on women, while Sam has to deal with the teenager’s home and school life.

Sam and Dean are tricked into attending a Supernatural convention by their super-fan Becky. Sam and Dean are in for a shock when many of the fans are dressed up like them.

While investigating a weird homicide apparently executed by the Incredible Hulk himself, Sam and Dean are trapped inside Dean’s favorite TV show, “Dr Sexy M.D.”. They suspect the Trickster of being a reason for it and try to confront him. Sam suggests, to a refusing Dean, that they convince the Trickster, who likes the earth and toying with its inhabitants, to help them end the Apocalypse. The Trickster, having been disguised as Dr Sexy, agrees under the condition that the brothers survive the following 24 hours. Since being trapped in “TV Land”, Sam and Dean have to endure numerous TV formats, including a Japanese game show, CSI: Miami and situation comedy. Castiel tries to save them, but is sent away by the Trickster. The brothers soon grow tired of the Trickster’s sick sense of humor and confront him again. However, bearing Castiel’s warning in mind that a demi-god couldn’t possibly be powerful enough to bring off something like this, they prepare a trap made of Holy Oil, which is able to capture an Archangel.

Mysterious deaths caused by inexplicable ageing lead Sam, Dean and Bobby to a warlock named Patrick who gambles for high stakes. He challenges people to a poker game in which they don’t play for money, but for life years represented by magical poker chips. Bobby sees this game as an opportunity to escape his wheelchair and accepts Patrick’s challenge. Losing the game, he begins to age rapidly. Dean wants to save Bobby and challenges the warlock to win back Bobby’s lost years to prevent him from dying. He bets 50 years, of which he uses 25 to reverse Bobby’s ageing process. However, Dean can’t keep up with the warlock’s poker skills and loses, which causes him to age. Together, the Winchester brothers and Bobby try to find a way to save Dean.

In Alliance, Nebraska, people are being killed by practical joke devices such as itching powder and joybuzzers. On top of that, a very odd looking Tooth Fairy extracts a man’s teeth. It turns out that an eleven-year-old boy named Jesse is the reason for all of this. Everything he believes becomes reality. After searching his birth records, Sam and Dean find out that the boy was adopted, so they visit his biological mother who lives across the state. She tells the brothers that she got pregnant from a demon possessing her and gave up her child for adoption after giving birth to him. Back in Alliance, Castiel informs the Winchesters that Jesse is an Antichrist, a being half human, half demon, embued with extraordinary powers. Therefore, an Antichrist could be Lucifer’s special weapon in the war against Heaven and, as a serious threat, needs to be eliminated. However, Sam and Dean believe that Jesse won’t turn evil if he’s taken somewhere safe.

Sam and Dean are reunited and on the hunt again. They reach a small town and investgate a string of very strange murders. A man who has found James Dean’s car “Little Bastard” is found dead as if he has been involved in a major car crash. Another man is murdered by someone who looks just like Abraham Lincoln. Suspecting that the murders are the work of famous ghosts, the boys do research at the local wax museum where Sam is attacked by what seems to be the ghost of Mahatma Ghandi. Shortly afterwards, two girls report to the police that their friend was kidnapped by Paris Hilton, which leaves the brothers speechless. After finding peculiar seeds in the victims’ stomachs, they break into the museum’s construction area where they do find Paris Hilton—who is in fact a pagan god in disguise, trying to settle down after its old home, a deep forest in Eastern Europe, has been cut down.